James Riley Crowley is a 3rd Great Uncle to my husband. I wrote a biography about James a few years ago. The biography is on Wiki under James Crowley.

I want to share a part of this biography that tells about three of James’s experiences with the law. He had three such experiences in the space of eleven years.

James migrated from Ray County, Missouri to Polk County, Oregon with his parents 1864. Here in Oregon, he married, started a family and acquired land. He first owned a farm in Perrydale, Polk County. Secondly, he owned land on Cascade Head, Tillamook County.

In June of 1882, his troubling times in Oregon courts began. James didn’t see the murder. He heard the gun shots and found the body.

The Nathan Nott Case

The first trial involved James’s hired hand who lived with the Crowleys. James was a key witness at two of these trials. In the first trial Nathan Nott, James’s hired hand, was tried for the murder of William Frakes.

The 1880 census for Salt Lake District, Polk, Oregon shows these people living in dwelling #132 with James R. Crowley, age 37. They are his wife, Martha C., age 31, his daughter Mary J., age 10, and two sons, Walter, age 3, and James R. (Ralph), age 1. Also, living here was a single farm worker from Illinois named Nathan L. Nott, age 30.

A disturbing news item from the Corvallis Gazette went to print on June 9, 1882. This article featured Crowley’s boarder, one, N. L. Nott.

Hired Hand commits a murder- Nott trial 

On Tuesday evening last week, William Frakes, an old resident of this county, was murdered at Bear Camp, on the Salmon River Road, by N.L. Nott, says the Dallas Itemizer. From the information we have been able to obtain it seems that Nott had formerly been keeping some stock for Mrs. Frakes on the shares and some misunderstanding arose regarding the matter. On Sunday last Mr. Frakes started from home to bring back a cow and calf, which had been in Nott’s possession, and which had been left on the range. On Tuesday Nott, James Crowley and Billy McKinney started from Salt Creek with some stock which they were taking to Salmon River. They met Frakes at the place where he was murdered, and it is said that Nott remarked to McKinney that he had a job to attend to, and left him and in a few minutes, shots were heard and Nott came back, announcing that he had killed Frakes

“Murder”, The Corvallis Gazette, (Corvallis, OR), 9 Jun 1882, p.3, col 1, (https://oregonnews.uoregon.edu/lccn/sn84022650/1882-06-09/ed-1/seq-3/

A second article printed on June 10, 1882, in the Eugene Guardian continued the story saying,

A Murderer Under Arrest 

McKinney was then sent to the house of Mr. Mulligan, about a mile distant, and when he arrived at the camp Crowley and Nott had eaten their supper and were there; Mr. Mulligan was requested to take the body to Perrydale, which he consented to do, and on Wednesday he brought the remains to the place named. Nott, Crowley and McKinney proceeded on their way to Salmon River. John Crowley started after them on Wednesday, and Nott was met by Sheriff Hall at Grand Ronde on Thursday. He claimed he had acted in self- defense and was coming back to give himself up. He was brought to Perrydale, and his examination postponed until Wednesday next. He is now in jail at this place. Frakes received four shots, one in the breast proving fatal. Both arms were broken and he was shot through the thigh It is supposed he was on his horse when shot.

“A murderer Under Arrest”, Eugene City Guardian (Eugene, Oregon), June 10, 1882, p 5, col. 2 near top (https://oregonnews.uoregon.edu/lccn/sn84022653/1882-06-10/ed-1/seq-5/#words=Frake+Frakes+Nott

• On July 29, 1882 Nott was on trial for killing William Frakes as the Polk County Itemizer went to print.
• Two weeks later the Polk County Itemizer reported that Nott had been found guilty of murder in the second degree.

Naoma Shelton vs John L Shelton

James’s younger sister, Naoma Crowley, was born when James was 17. On October 25, 1880 Naoma married John Lawrence Shelton at the home of John’s mother. They had four boys. When Naoma was 32 years-old, she filed for divorce.

James and John had known each since 1873. Both were farmers living in the vicinity of Dallas, Oregon. Naoma met John much later.

In April of 1891 James rescued his younger sister, Naoma Crowley Shelton, from a house in Portland, Multnomah, Oregon. In Portland she lived with her four boys and her abusive husband, John Lawrence Shelton. James took her and her sons to his home near Dallas, Oregon. She filed for divorce on April 10, 1891. The case came to court on May 10, 1892. Naoma was 32 and still living in Dallas, as did James Crowley.

James said in his testimony he had known John L. Shelton for 18 years and Naoma all her life. He also said that John had ran through Naoma’s property. She had owned 400 acres of land when they married. John drank and gambled it away. Here is a partial transcript of James’s testimony:

James’s Testimony

 She wrote me that he was treating her so badly that she could not live with him, so I went and brought her to Dallas. At that time, they were living in Multnomah County. He accused her of being intimate with other men in my presence. When I went after her, she told me that he had been abusing her, that she couldn’t live with him and was afraid to do so. When I went after her, I found her and her children almost destitute of clothing. On a number of occasions, I heard him use abusive language toward her. After she came to my house, he came there drunk and used such abusive language towards her that on two or three different times, I was compelled to put him out of the house.

Circuit Court of the State of Oregon, Polk County, Divorce Record, Naomi Shelton vs John Shelton, Record # 16009, Case #2247, Oregon State Archives, Salem Oregon, in the files of Jill Foster

Here is a copy of the last page of James’s testimony with his signature.

Bowker’s Trial

James’s next exposure to Oregon’s legal system came in the summer of 1893. The court at Dallas, Oregon subpoenaed him and his sister Naoma Shelton as witnesses at the Bowker’s Trial.

Charles A. Bowker, who worked the Southern Pacific railroads at the time of his arrest, had been a Baptist preacher. Charles had delivered services at the Baptist Church in Dallas attended by the Crowleys. When he was preaching in Dallas he was respected and well-liked.

Charles was the fireman on the evening train running between McMinnville and Portland. He was arrested and tried for manslaughter in Portland. It seems he got a young woman pregnant, a seventeen-year-old named Helen Wilson. This happened in Portland, Oregon. Charles was charged with having arranged the abortion which killed Helen.

In this first trial Charles was acquitted. But, more trials were conducted and he was charged and spent time in prison. In November of 1894, he secured a new trial, and he was released on bail. This case eventually went to the Oregon Supreme Court. The Oregon Supreme Court reversed Charles’s conviction and he was acquitted.

More Troubles

It would seem that these three court cases would be enough for one man to bear. But in 1893, James’s wife died.

The announcement of Martha’s death was made in several Oregon newspapers. She died of cancer at her Dallas home on Tuesday, June 13, 1893. The family buried her at Crowley, Oregon in the Oak Grove Cemetery (Etna Cemetery) on Thursday, June 22 1893.